【最大的福份】GREATEST FORTUNE
(English writing below)
哇~~~線上視訊諮詢真好玩!😃
我剛結束為在紐西蘭客人批八字的線上視訊。這是我第一次做視訊諮詢。
我一向比較喜歡當面會面,所以海外客人可選擇來新加坡見我,或付費請我給過去。
但是中華玄學提倡的就是要隨機應變。無論現在生活如何的安穩,人要時時居安思危,懂得變通,更要隨時準備就緒,才能把握時機,甚至從危機中脫穎而出。
畢竟如《易經》所說,唯一不變的是變化。
世事無常,沒有永遠的好,也沒有永遠的壞。
止步不前的人永遠不會進步。
這位客人關注我的臉書已有幾年的時間。
當她請我為她批八字時,我一口答應接下這差事。
幾年前,我寫過一篇文章,提到風水命理師都要能夠及願意代客人的業,因此我們很多同行都是佛教徒。
這位女士當時就私訊我,想以我的名義捐款,為我祈福。她請我選一個我喜歡的慈善機構。
我拒絕了她的好意。因為我認為自己的人生選擇,應該自己去承擔。
現在也輪到我以我的所長來答謝她。
視訊裡,我看到她一部份的居家擺設,並道出那是漏財之相,會無緣無故花了很多錢,卻又不知道錢去了哪裡,財富無法增長。
客人點頭同意,說家裡確實有這樣的問題。
我指點她該如何化解這風水問題。
雖然這次不是看風水,但我不會忘記,誰曾經施恩於我的。
在二月份時,我寫信給我的根本上師聖尊蓮生活佛,求「救瘟疫度母」持咒灌頂。
幾個星期前,我收到回信。
回信中,結尾恭錄著師尊文集《神變的遊歷》裡的一段話:
“有很多修行人的「庫藏」,裡面是充滿智慧的法本,他們將智慧握在手中,「庫藏」內並不一定有什麼福份,他們只是將智慧發光,使一切眾生得到成就,而他們的福份就是「自在」。”
我家師兄讀了之後,緊張地拿著信來問我:「你是不是在信裡跟師尊求財,然後祂的意思是跟你說你命中沒有嗎?為什麼信會這樣子回覆你?」
真是好氣又好笑。
「沒有啊!我只求持咒灌頂,其他都沒有求。」
但你知道嗎?
這也正是我此生唯一的所求。沒有什麼比這更值得拼上我一生的青春了。
為明天四小時的視訊諮詢準備咯!
_______________________
Ooooh, consultations via video calls are FUN! 😃
I just concluded my very first video call for a Bazi analysis of a client in New Zealand.
I always prefer to meet in person, so either overseas clients come to Singapore to meet me or they pay for me to fly over.
But Chinese Metaphysics is always about being flexible and prepared for change, no matter how comfortable we may be in our current state. After all, as I-Ching states, the only constant is change.
Nothing lasts forever, be it good or bad.
Nobody progresses by staying put.
This client has been following my Facebook for several years.
When she approached me to analyse her Bazi, I agreed right away.
Years ago, I wrote a post on how Feng Shui practitioners must be able and willing to take over the negative karma of clients, hence many of us are Buddhist practitioners.
This lady PM me and offered to do a donation under my name, as she wished to send me some blessings. She asked me to choose a charity.
I kindly declined. Because I should take personal responsibility for my choices in life.
Now is my time to thank her with what I am competent at.
During the video call, I saw a part of her home. I told her that was a sign of leaking wealth. Money would be spent carelessly without knowing where it goes, and it gets harder to grow the family wealth.
The client nodded in agreement with my observation, and said this was indeed the current situation.
While this may not be a Feng Shui audit, I went ahead to tell her the way to resolve it.
Because I never forget who had shown kindness to me.
In February, I wrote a letter to my Grandmaster His Holiness Living Buddha Lian-Sheng to seek empowerment for the mantra of the Tara who saves from contagious diseases.
I received the reply a few weeks ago.
Interestingly, the letter ended with a short paragraph extracted from my Grandmaster’s book:
“In the treasury storage of many spiritual cultivators, lies many Dharma books of wisdom. They hold the wisdom in their hands.
There may not be much good fortune in their treasury storage. They just add shine of brilliance to the wisdom, so that all sentient beings can achieve accomplishments.
And their blessedness is freedom from worldly restraints.”
The husband read the letter and asked me panicking, “ Did you ask Grandmaster to grant you riches or something? He said you are not destined for wealth, is it? Why did the letter write that?”
“No! I never asked for anything, except the empowerment!”
But you know what?
This is all that I wish for till the end of my life. Nothing else will ever be worth my youth.
Onward to another 4-hour video call tomorrow!
同時也有1部Youtube影片,追蹤數超過4萬的網紅謙預 QianyuSG,也在其Youtube影片中提到,你的命運,你的人生應該「隨緣」嗎? 你有資格說「隨緣」嗎? 當你說「隨緣」時,是隨誰的緣?為什麼要隨別人的緣? 還是你真實的意思,是要說「隨便」? Should You Leave Your Destiny to Fate? Are you qualified to say that? **...
「metaphysics意思」的推薦目錄:
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 謙預 Qianyu.sg Facebook 的最佳解答
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 玳瑚師父 Master Dai Hu Facebook 的精選貼文
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 謙預 Qianyu.sg Facebook 的最讚貼文
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 謙預 QianyuSG Youtube 的最佳解答
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 Re: [形上學筆記]What is 'metaphysics' - 精華區W-Philosophy 的評價
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 Introduction to Aristotle's Natural Philosophy and Metaphysics 的評價
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 形而上学Metaphysics - Facebook 的評價
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 網路上關於形而上學意思-在PTT/MOBILE01/Dcard上的升學 ... 的評價
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 網路上關於形而上學意思-在PTT/MOBILE01/Dcard上的升學 ... 的評價
- 關於metaphysics意思 在 網路上關於形而上學意思-在PTT/MOBILE01/Dcard上的升學 ... 的評價
metaphysics意思 在 玳瑚師父 Master Dai Hu Facebook 的精選貼文
(English version below)
八字殿堂深又廣,
無限訊息當中藏,
一般衹向俗課談,
豈知佛魔亦可探。
八字是我們過去世,功過的因果密碼。就因爲是密碼,所以眞知者,根本就不會太多。除非,這個人願意投入,其大量的生命時光,專注且不停的鑽研及驗證,再加上其天賦,才能學上手。要不然,就會誤己誤人,嚇己嚇人,這一世消業不成,反添新業障啊!
那位想去泰國會見,其萍水相逢女子的男子,用個新手機號碼,致電於吾說想向吾學佛。談話中,他說他有聽取吾建議,沒去泰國見那女子,不過他有去找另外一位女子。吾聽了,再一次的讚嘆我們祖先,留給我們的智慧遺產,玄學。
這位男子若不是視力差,就是呆子了。因爲,吾已慈悲他多次,讓他來吾舉辦的餐會,不下五次,並當面拆穿他八字裡,及其心裡的魔,他應清楚不過,吾是何等人物才是呀!更何況,他其实有在悄悄的學,可惜六毒不除,魔在頭上啊!
從一個人的八字,是可以知道她他的喜、怒、哀、樂、狂的發生時間與地點,甚至何人會使她他這樣。同樣也可以通過八字來把脈,後對症下藥。比如近年幼孩的剋星,令父母傷心的川奇症或冰淇症。對不起,好像沒有冰淇症是嗎?是是是,是沒有。是吾喜歡八寶冰,不好意思,不好意思,希望沒嚇着大家。一笑。
吾想說的是,玄學的高手,一看川奇症,立馬就知曉對治方法。若妳你想知道,更想對治妳你所面對的魔,歡迎拜訪。
.......................
Bazi is the karmic secret code of the merits and faults from our past lives. Because it is a secret code, there are not many people who truly comprehend it.
If this person is willing to invest an enormous amount of his/her lifetime, is focused, carries out studies and verification tests of this subject matter, and has the gift for it, then he/she will be able to master it.
Otherwise, apart from himself/herself, the person will also mislead and frighten others. This will increase the karmic obstacles in this lifetime, instead of reducing them.
There was this gentleman who had wanted to go Thailand to see a lady he met by chance. He called me with a new mobile number, expressing his interest to learn Buddhism from me.
In our conversation, he said he heeded my advice not to fly to Thailand to meet that lady. However, he went to look for another lady instead. After hearing his words, I was once again in praises of our ancestors, for leaving us with this wisdom heritage - Chinese Metaphysics.
If this gentleman does not have poor vision, he must be a fool. Because I, out of compassion, have allowed him to come for my learning sessions and dissected his Bazi, telling him what his inner demons were. He should know what kind of person I am.
Moreover, he had been learning secretly. It was a pity he could not eradicate his six poisons, and Mara was sitting right on top of him!
From a person's Bazi, I can tell the times and locations that will elicit his/her happiness, anger, sadness, joy, madness, and even the people that caused such emotions in him/her. Similarly, I can use Bazi to take the pulse and prescribe the right medicine for the illnesses. For example, in recent years, there is this bane of an illness that strikes young children, causing distress in many parents - the Kawasaki Disease, or the Ice Disease. Oh, sorry, there seems to be no Ice Disease, right? Yes yes yes, indeed there is not. It is me who like Eight Treasures Shaved Ice. Sorry, sorry, I hope I did not scare you. *laughs*
What I wish to say is, as an expert in Chinese Metaphysics, it only takes a look to know the antidote for Kawasaki Disease. If you wish to know, and have a stronger desire to cure the demons you face, you are welcome to visit me.
metaphysics意思 在 謙預 Qianyu.sg Facebook 的最讚貼文
【業力的黑洞】THE BLACK HOLE OF KARMA
(一)
「我不是叫你帶筆記本嗎?」
我看著男客人擺在桌上的那僅僅一張A4紙。
男客人不好意思地說:「我忘了。這是跟櫃台取的。」
「我千里迢迢來到這裡,因為你說你要改命。你就拿這樣一張借來的紙,來改命?一個半小時的看八字,夠你寫嗎?還是你不夠寫時,又要浪費我的時間去借紙?你的認真在哪裡?」
我雙眼直視著男客人的眼睛。
他連忙站起來,去借了多幾張A4紙。
•
(二)
「你怎麼帶那麼小的本子?夠寫嗎?」
我不可思議的看著,那如信用卡一般大的記事本。
男客人答:「可以啦!我只寫重點!」
「你這個是懶。我的每一句話都是重點。你的八字在我手上,你是怎樣的人,你不要以為我不知道。你不要跟我瞎掰,更不要有寫沒寫的,然後事後又發私訊重覆性的問回我一樣的問題,因為你沒有用心思寫下來。樓上有書店,要嘛你現在去買,我給你十五分鐘,要嘛我們今天就不看你的八字。你自己選。」
男客人十分鐘內,買了A4本子。
•
(三)
我為即將結婚的男客人看新家風水。
他來過我的風水講座數次,閱讀我臉書也有兩年多時間,應該很熟悉我的性格。事前,我提醒過他兩次要帶筆記本,兩次兩次他都跟我說謝謝提醒。
站在客廳看風水時,他抽出那張A4的屋子平面圖,壓在手掌心寫。
「我不是已經叫你帶筆記本嗎?」
他笑笑不語,沒有解釋,沒有道歉。
新家風水那麼重要,關係到你和你家人未來至少五年的興旺,你就在這一張軟綿綿的紙上寫兩個小時的筆記嗎?
以我對客人的要求,我本會叫他到外頭買筆記本,我們才繼續看風水。
但那天,現任屋主還住在那個單位,是特別約好時間讓我們進去看風水,對方也在等著我們完事後就要出門。
想想他過去兩年來常在我臉書貼文按讚,就給他一點面子,讓他在女朋友面前好下台,也算是報答他的支持。
於是,我看在眼裡,記在心裡。依我的經驗,沒把筆記寫好的,必會再來問我。
幾天後,他來訊詢問。當中有幾個問題,我當天已解說過。
我回他:「我雖不介意回答已經回答過的問題,但如果你那一天有帶筆記本,你必會抄下來。」
也就不用再問。
我也寫道:「我對你有點失望。」
他回我:「我明白也注意到你的失望。以後會更留意自己的念頭和舉止。」
「你應該跟我道歉。你忽視我的善意提醒本就不對。」
也猶如騙了我。如果你當初不想帶,直說,不要以假謝謝敷衍。
男客人過後道歉,也大方的同意我把這件事情寫出來,警惕大家。
如果你的未來註定會坎坷,無論是婚姻、事業、家庭或財富,你要比任何人都更注意你的一舉一動。
因為你細小的念頭,細微的決定,會一步一步引你掉入你命中註定的歹運。
你會漏掉寫下我千交代萬交代的事情。
你會寫錯、聽錯、記錯、做錯。
你身邊的人會影響你,告訴你不要聽我或任何能幫你改命的話,你如何如何讓她他不開心不舒服。
你會有錢也不要出錢,只是一直想博取我的同情,得到免費的幫助,然後稱說自己沒有錢。
你會任性,你會執著,你會覺得風水命理沒那麼厲害,你自己說了算,雖然你根本不怎麼樣。
因為你已變成一個弦线上的小木偶,被你那無情的業力操控著。
我的嚴厲,是要及時拉你一把,不要「青青菜菜」的過活,不要拖累你的家人和你一起遭業報。
不是每個人跌倒後,都能夠爬得起來。
誰不想做好人,讓每個人都喜歡自己?但自古,慈母多敗兒。
在現今社會裡,男人女人的自信,都是來自於事業,但每個人的幸福,都是源自於家庭。
所以千萬千萬不要自私。
...................................
(1)
“Didn't I tell you to bring a notebook?"
I looked at the lonely piece of A4 paper the male client placed on the table.
Slightly embarrassed, the male client said, "I forgot. This was obtained from the counter."
"I come all the way here because you tell me you want to change your destiny. You bring this kind of paper to change your life? My consultation is 1.5 hour and you think it's enough for you to write? Or when you run out of space, are you going to waste my time to go and borrow paper? Where is your seriousness?"
I looked at the male client straight in the eyes.
He hurriedly stood up and borrowed a few more pieces of A4 paper.
•
(2)
"Why did you bring such a small notebook? How is it enough for you to write?"
I looked at the credit-card-sized notebook incredulously.
The male client replied, "Can! I only write the important points!"
"This is your sloth. Everything I said is important. Your Bazi is in my hands. Don't think that I do not know what kind of person you are. Don't talk nonsense to me. Don't write selectively and then later send me PMs asking me the same questions that I have answered in this consultation, just because you didn't put in effort to jot it down. There is a bookshop upstairs. Either you go and buy now. I will give you 15 minutes. Or we will cancel today's consultation. You decide."
The male client returned with a brand new A4 notebook in ten minutes.
•
(3)
I was doing a Feng Shui audit for a male client who was getting married.
He came to my Feng Shui workshops a few times and have read my Facebook for over 2 years. Prior to the audit, I reminded him twice to bring a notebook and twice, he thanked me for my reminders.
While standing in the living room doing the Feng Shui audit, he drew out a A4-sized floorplan and wrote on it, with his palm as the backing.
"Didn't I already tell you to bring a notebook?"
He smiled back at me. No explanation. No apology.
The Feng Shui of a new home is so important because it determines the future of your family luck for at least the next 5 years. And you are going to write on this floppy piece of paper for the next 2 hours?
Given my expectations of clients, I would have told him to go and buy a notebook before I continued my audit.
But that day, the current owner was still living in the unit. It was by appointment that we were let in to get the Feng Shui audit done. The family was also waiting for us to finish things up, as they were going out.
I thought of the many times that he had Liked my FB posts these two years. So I decided to give him some face, and not make things difficult for him in front of his girlfriend. Also a very tiny way of me thanking him for his support all these while.
Hence, I put this incident in my heart. From my experience, I know that anyone who did not write the notes well will definitely come back to ask me again.
A few days later, he sent me messages, some of which were raising the same questions that I had explained on the day of the audit.
I told him, "While I do not mind answering the same questions again, if you had brought a notebook that day, you would have written it down."
You and I would not need to repeat ourselves again.
I also wrote, "I am slightly disappointed in you."
His reply, "Well noted on your disappointment. Will pay attention to own thoughts/actions for better changes."
"You should apologise to me. It is wrong of you to ignore my reminders to bring a notebook."
This is akin to lying to me. If you do not wish to bring, say it outright. Don't brush me off with perfunctory thanks.
He did apologised later and graciously gave me the permission to write about this, to remind my readers.
If your future is destined to be difficult, be it in your marriage, career, family or wealth, you must be extra observant of your every action and deed.
Because every little thought of yours, every seemingly minor decision you made, will lead you step-by-step to fall into the manhole of your pre-destined bad fortune.
You will miss out on what I repeatedly tell you to do.
You will write wrongly, hear wrongly, remember wrongly and do wrongly.
The people around you will influence you. They will tell you not to listen to me, or any well-meaning advice to transform your destiny. They will say that you doing so is making them unhappy and uncomfortable.
You will be unwillingly to fork out money even when you can afford it. You want to live off the compassion of mine and get free help, on the empty claim that you have no money.
You will be wilful. You will be stubborn. You will think that there is no big deal about Chinese Metaphysics and that what you say matters the most in your life. Despite not having any ability or past achievement to support that fat bold claim.
Because you have already become that little string puppet, being dangled around mercilessly by your negative karma.
My sternness is to pull you away from that manhole of mishaps. Do not live your life in a blur. Do not drag your family down with you to suffer at the hands of karma.
Not everyone can stand up right again, after a really bad fall.
Who doesn't wish to be that well-liked person? But since ancient times, an overly loving mother often leads to a useless son.
In modern society, the self confidence of every man and woman tend to come from his/her career. But happiness and bliss will always come from your family.
So never ever choose to be selfish.
metaphysics意思 在 謙預 QianyuSG Youtube 的最佳解答
你的命運,你的人生應該「隨緣」嗎?
你有資格說「隨緣」嗎?
當你說「隨緣」時,是隨誰的緣?為什麼要隨別人的緣?
還是你真實的意思,是要說「隨便」?
Should You Leave Your Destiny to Fate?
Are you qualified to say that?
******************************
阿彌陀佛,你好!我是李季謙,來自新加坡的風水命理師。我將我的一生貢獻於弘揚佛法和中華玄學。這過程曲折離奇,卻也充滿了許多人生的領悟。
通過我的影音與寫作,我希望能與你分享,盼你也能夠突破自己命運的束縛,真正活得精彩:我命在我,不在天。
人生長短無所謂,最重要的是活得有價值,有貢獻。
***********
Hi, I am Lee Ji Qian, a Chinese Metaphysics practitioner from Singapore. This journey in propagating Buddhism and Chinese Metaphysics has been full of hard knocks and exciting discoveries.
Through my videos and online writing, I hope to share my journey with you. So that you too can break free from the limits of your destiny and truly live a life you can call exciting. My destiny is in my own hands, not Heaven. So is yours.
It does not matter whether we can live a long or short life.
What matters most is living a life of value and contribution.
??? 服務諮詢 FOR MY SERVICES:
http://www.qianyu.sg/consultations
? CONNECT WITH ME HERE:
http://www.facebook.com/qianyuSG
https://www.instagram.com/qianyusg/
??? 服務諮詢 FOR MY SERVICES:
http://www.qianyu.sg/consultations
? CONNECT WITH ME HERE:
http://www.facebook.com/qianyuSG
https://www.instagram.com/qianyusg/
*** 我使用的器材 OTHER TECH EQUIPMENT I USE ***
這支影片 FOR THIS VIDEO:
Iphone 6
Wide Angle Selfie Ring Light
3-in-1 Monopod: https://amzn.to/2rJ1M03
Royal Voice Lavalier Mic (out of production)
this comes close : https://amzn.to/2pmj7Ly
相機 CAMERAS
Sony A6400: https://amzn.to/33NLssT
Sony 128GB SD card: https://amzn.to/2NKv6vw
Rode Videomicro : https://amzn.to/350TZsW
Sony Mark III: https://amzn.to/2qOne3g
128GB SD card: https://amzn.to/2Qfnl2n
有聲書錄音器材 AUDIOBOOK RECORDING
Neumann T102: https://amzn.to/34XuFE3
Universal Audio: https://amzn.to/2CIOgM4
Portabooth Plus: https://amzn.to/33MyBHE
其他配件ACCESSORIES:
Zhiyun Crane M Gimbal: https://amzn.to/2Xfd7QZ
Nitecore charger for A6400: https://amzn.to/2Qfo8QT
Extra Sony A6400 battery: https://amzn.to/2Kh3oo8
********************************
Music:
––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
Light by Jorge Mendez https://youtu.be/52509xgZKDI
Lights by Sappheiros https://soundcloud.com/sappheirosmusic
Creative Commons — Attribution 3.0 Unported — CC BY 3.0
Free Download / Stream: https://bit.ly/LightsSappheiros
Music promoted by Audio Library https://youtu.be/-lbbHQbZNKg
––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
metaphysics意思 在 Introduction to Aristotle's Natural Philosophy and Metaphysics 的推薦與評價
留言加分享本貼文就有機會抽《亞里斯多德哲學導論》一本。📅參加抽獎活動時間為期一週:2023.5.21 - 2023.5.28👍 感謝五南出版熱情贈書-立刻加入頻道 ... ... <看更多>
metaphysics意思 在 形而上学Metaphysics - Facebook 的推薦與評價
形而上学[1],哲学研究中的一個範疇。被視為「第一哲学」、哲學的基本問題。 字源. 英語metaphysics 或拉丁語metaphysica一詞源自希腊語:μετά(metá),意思是之后或 ... ... <看更多>
metaphysics意思 在 Re: [形上學筆記]What is 'metaphysics' - 精華區W-Philosophy 的推薦與評價
想問問版主一個非常弱的問題:
關于形而上的東西應該怎麼讀呢?
我兩年前買了一本小邏輯,讀了2年了,開頭看了至少十幾遍,讀到中間就讀不下去了
每次都半途而廢,想請教一下。
※ 引述《popandy (pop)》之銘言:
: 亞里斯多德當初寫關於「Metaphysics」(形上學)的作品時,用的是「First
: Philosophy」(第一哲學)這個字。從古希臘文的字義來看,「First」是最基礎、
: 最根本的意思,「Philosophy」是學問的意思,所以「First Philosophy」指的是最
: 基礎的學問。後來編纂亞里斯多德作品的人,將所有論「First Philosophy」的作
: 品集成書,取名為「Metaphysics」,可能因為「First Philosophy」在「Physics」
: 的作品「之後」(字根Meta-的一種意思)寫成,也可能因為「First Philosophy」
: 比「Physics」更基礎,「超越」了「Physics」(字根Meta-的另一種意思)。
: 粗略地說,黑格爾以前的形上學家,企圖找出大自然中最基礎的原則,比
: 物理學的定律更基礎,並且支持著各種自然科學所找到的規律。在亞里斯多德那
: 個時候,「物理學」是廣義地指涉,探究自然世界中各種變化的現象背後不變的
: 規律的學問。那時候己經有物種的概念,而且知道種子會長成樹,不會長成動物
: 這類的規律。但是為何有這類的規律呢?或者問,這類規律背後有沒有更基礎,
: 更終極的形上原則,支持著一切?亞里斯多德的「第一哲學」當中便指出,這種
: 規律背後更基礎的規律是:每個東西都有本性(essence),並且具有潛能
: (potentiality),使自己發展成實際(reality)。由上可粗略地見到,黑格爾
: 以前的形上學家如何發展形上學的理論。
: 相較於亞里斯多德,黑格爾基於相近的目的,開展出一套體系之龐大前所未
: 有的哲學理論,形上學當然更是這整個龐大體系的核心部份。不過黑格爾以後,
: 哲學家不再如此,而是針對特定問題提出詳盡的論證,通過正反的辯駁,釐清問
: 題的內涵。形上學當然也不例外,當代形上學關注的問題有:人是否有「自由意
: 志」(Free Will)?「實際」(reality)與「表象」(appearence)的關係為
: 何?如果「表象」是隨著時間在變化,我們如何判斷經過變化的一物仍然是原來
: 那一物?也就是如何判斷其同一性(identity)?例如,醫學上說人經過八年後
: 全身細胞都換新了,那我如何說八年前的我就是現在的我?嚴格地說,我根據什
: 麼判準決定,八年前的我就是現在的我?人會感到悲傷、難過,機器卻不會,這
: 是否代表著人有「心靈」(mind)?
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 211.151.89.114
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------- <
作者: popandy (pop) 看板: W-Philosophy
標題: [形上學筆記]What is there besides Body?
時間: Mon Sep 27 12:15:08 2004
我的身體看起來就跟一般的物質沒什麼兩樣,佔有空間,具有質量,可以被我觀察
到,而且符合各種力學定律,是機械性的。的確,以主流的科學觀而言,我的身體跟一
般的物質一樣,都是由原子構成,當然具有以上性質。
除此以外,身體還有什麼性質呢?每個人都有難過的經驗,考試考不好,女朋友落
跑,更糟的是期末考有一科將決定我是否被二一的命運!也就是說,我有情緒,我會悲
傷、難過、焦慮。廣義地說,我具有「情緒性」。每個人也都有絞盡腦汁思考數學問題
的經驗,也就是說,我會思考。廣義地說,我具有「思考性」。那麼,我可以說我的身
體具有「情緒性」及「思考性」嗎?這顯然說不通!假如我路上遇到你,還跟你說我的
手在思考要不要跟你打招呼。你一定覺得我瘋了,盡講些沒道理的話。可見身體不具「
情緒性」及「思考性」,而是我有另一部份具有這些性質。
更深入地探討我的這兩種活動可以發現,我「內在的」情緒狀態及想法,是肉眼「
觀察不到的」,無論是別人或是自己。另外,我可以「自由地」想像自己身處世界的任
何一地,自由地吃,自由地睡。由此可見,我還有一部份是「內在的」、「觀察不到的
」、「自由的」。常識上我們稱這部分為「心靈」。「心靈」與「身體」相互對比的性
質可歸結如下:
身體 心靈
佔有空間的(spatial) 不佔有空間的()
機械性的(mechanical) 自由的(free)
物質性的(material) 非物質性的(immaterial)
可觀察的(observable) 不可觀察的(unobservable)
外在的(outer) 內在的(inner)
不能思考的(unthinking) 能思考的(thinking)
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.112.7.59
※ 編輯: popandy 來自: 140.112.25.194 (09/29 20:32)
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------- <
作者: A1Yoshi (寬廣 無際) 看板: W-Philosophy
標題: Re: [形上學筆記]What is there besides Body?
時間: Mon Sep 27 13:00:37 2004
※ 引述《popandy (pop)》之銘言:
: 我的身體看起來就跟一般的物質沒什麼兩樣,佔有空間,具有質量,可以被我觀察
: 到,而且符合各種力學定律,是機械性的。的確,以主流的科學觀而言,我的身體跟一
: 般的物質一樣,都是由原子構成,當然具有以上性質。
: 除此以外,身體還有什麼性質呢?每個人都有難過的經驗,考試考不好,女朋友落
: 跑,更糟的是期末考有一科將決定我是否被二一的命運!也就是說,我有情緒,我會悲
: 傷、難過、焦慮。廣義地說,我具有「情緒性」。每個人也都有絞盡腦汁思考數學問題
: 的經驗,也就是說,我會思考。廣義地說,我具有「思考性」。那麼,我可以說我的身
: 體具有「情緒性」及「思考性」嗎?這顯然說不通!假如我路上遇到你,還跟你說我的
: 手在思考要不要跟你打招呼。你一定覺得我瘋了,盡講些沒道理的話。可見身體不具「
: 情緒性」及「思考性」,而是我有另一部份具有這些性質。
嗯,手也許真的沒有情緒性與思考性,可是這並不表示身體就不會有。手也只是身體的
一部份。比方說,車子能有一個性質是它能以時速一百公里的速度前進,但這它的一部
份,比方說:車門,就沒有那個性質。
所以從手沒有,推到身體沒有是有問題的。
: 更深入地探討我的這兩種活動可以發現,我「內在的」情緒狀態及想法,是肉眼「
: 觀察不到的」,無論是別人或是自己。另外,我可以「自由地」想像自己身處世界的任
: 何一地,自由地吃,自由地睡。由此可見,我還有一部份是「內在的」、「觀察不到的
: 」、「自由的」。常識上我們稱這部分為「心靈」。「心靈」與「身體」相互對比的性
: 質可歸結如下:
用是否可以肉眼觀察,來判斷內在外在可能也是不恰當的。我後腦的頭皮除非借重鏡子,
否則也無法以肉眼觀察。所以後腦的頭皮是內在的嗎?
: 身體 心靈
: 佔有空間的(spatial) 不佔有空間的()
: 機械性的(mechanical) 自由的(free)
: 物質性的(material) 非物質性的(immaterial)
: 可觀察的(observable) 不可觀察的(unobservable)
: 外在的(outer) 內在的(inner)
: 不能思考的(unthinking) 能思考的(thinking)
我想,這應該是笛卡爾的實體二元論吧?把「心」視為是一種存在的實體,和物理實體
具有不一樣的性質。但對於等同論者(Identity theorists)來說,就可能不是這樣囉
。對性質二元論者來說也不是這樣。對功能論者來說,也可能不是這樣。
所以我建議,這筆記最好強調一下,這是哪一類的主張,代表人物有誰。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.129.70.52
※ 編輯: A1Yoshi 來自: 140.129.70.52 (09/27 14:17)
... <看更多>